I think Harry would've been saved. But this question did make me think. When Harry was hit by the Killing Curse, it's Dumbledore that he talks to. Dumbledore makes it very clear that it is Harry's choice to stay or "get on the train". If he would've been hit by the curse, who would've been there? I would assume that the person has to be dead to have talked to Harry, but at this point in the book there is no one that Harry trusts who is dead. So, I think the magic would've worked, but in a different way.

Aragog141: I did debate mentioning his parents, and then that started making me spin some pretty wild theories. Would his parents have been able to separate themselves as much as Dumbledore was able to?

But is the blood that anchors Harry the blood that Voldemort took, or would the bloodline he shares with Petunia work as well? After all, the charm was sealed when Petunia took Harry in. So does Petunia have a bit of this magic inside her as well? Certainly, Harry does not have all his layers of protection at the time (Horcrux, blood, wand, and Hallows are what I consider his layers of protections, and at this point, obviously, the Hallows are missing and we're discussing the blood, so...) so would he have been less able to defend himself? He also didn't know Expelliarmus, which is his counter-attack (nearly always) against Voldemort's Killing Curses. If, however, Petunia's blood would keep him anchored, I think he would have had a choice, but would be far more likely to choose to go on to be with his parents. They are, at this point, the only people he has lost, and he doesn't have as many people to go back to either. If Petunia's blood does not offer that anchor, then I think Harry would have died.

I think Harry would not have died because if Quirrell can not touch Harry, his curse can not "touch" him, too.
But if Harry had died the part of Voldemort's soul would have died, too. It would not be a much shorter story because someone else would have the task to destroy the horcruxes and Voldemort. Maybe this would be a book series about Ron and Hermione or maybe about Neville.

Eule ist the German word for owl.

I just think Harry's Horcrux would have died.

Or maybe the protection would still be intact, because as we know, it breaks when Harry becomes of age. Either way, there would still be another book>

In Deathly Hallows, Dumbledore tells Snape during The Prince's Tale that it's very important that Voldemort himself be the one to kill Harry. So does that mean that the only way Harry could have had the King's Cross moment was if the one who creates the Horcrux, Voldemort, is also the one to kill the Horcrux? If so, then I think any killing curse Quirrell would try would only kill Harry and not the piece of Voldemort's soul meaning Harry would have died and not returned.

Ah, but Dumbledore says, "Of course it's all in your head Harry, but why on earth should that mean it is not real?" So it could not just be in Harry's head...we'll never know! We also have to remember that Quirrell has Voldemort attached to his soul, so I think it would have been just like Voldemort killing him. Harry was certainly in danger, even if Petunia's blood was tying him to life, just as he was when Voldemort taking his blood was tying him to life. I think Quirrell is certainly capable of casting the Killing Curse; he was a Ravenclaw after all, he does have quite an good brain (though he didn't seem to use it when he went looking for Voldemort...)

The question you've posed makes me wonder that if Quirrel/Voldemort had indeed succeeded in casting the Avada Kedavra curse, would Harry perhaps not die but instead because of Lily's original "love-magic," history would repeat itself and he (Harry) would get another scar? Or perhaps his present scar would become deeper and Voldemort could more easily penetrate his mind as he does often throughout the series.

Whether or not Petunia is anchoring Harry to earth, there's no reason to believe that the love magic wouldn't work again. From the Pottermore quote that was in the podcast, we learn that Quirrell was "greatly depleted" by fighting Voldemort's soul. So, like a parasite, Voldemort was gradually taking over Quirrell's body/soul/mind. When the curse was cast, I'd say that Quirrell was at least 75% Voldemort and 25% himself. So it was Voldemort's curse and only the Harry Horcrux would have been destroyed.
But what would have happened to Voldemort? In King's Cross, Dumbledore says that his soul was so unstable that it split apart unintentionally when he tried to kill Harry the first time. What if it split again? Could Voldemort have destroyed the Harry Horcrux and then made another Harry Horcrux? We also know that Voldemort at least blacked out when Harry "died" in DH. Did he go to a King's Cross-type place as well? If he did, he would have done so in PS if Quirrell had cast the curse? Would he have the strength to return without a body to return to? We know he can't die because of all the other Horcruxes. So would he have been stuck between life and death forever?
Also, I started wondering whether the love magic only works against Voldemort's *magic*. What if Voldemort had simply tried to behead Harry with a sword? Would Harry have died without any King's Cross moments? We know that regular Horcruxes can't be destroyed by mundane means, so if Lily's magic worked, would the Harry Horcrux have been destroyed?
Sorry, I didn't mean to ask so many questions, but this question generates a lot of what ifs!

Personally, I think Harry would have died because Voldemort didn't have Harry's blood in his veins. There was nothing anchoring him to life - Harry only survived when he was an infant because Lily sacrificed herself. During that scene, there was no one to sacrifice their life for Harry, so Harry wouldn't survive.

I don't think Harry would've survived. While there is a connection to Petunia's blood, as many have argued, I believe that connection is purely a part of the Fidelus Charm, which we know only works as a measure to keep Harry hidden, not safe in the event of Voldemort finding him.

J.K. has also stated before that the whole love-magic thing isn't a simple equation and that even in GoF it's not as easy as Lily's protection+Voldemort taking blood+twin cores= Harry survives. Therefore I think that it's not as easy as saying that Lily's blood would protect him, because that kind of magic is so complex. If it was the case that Harry wouldn't have died that would basically have made him unbeatable, at least for Voldemort (if there is a connection there between it having been his curse that Lily so to speak blocked). It is never suggested by anyone (read Dumbledore) that Harry can not be killed wherefore I think it's probable that Harry would have died had a killing curse been cast.

There are numerous items that infant need while they are just apart, such as gucci wallets, changing mat, diapers, meal, toys and most even more. A top quality together with smartly-designed gucci wallet are an essential essential need so which usually mom might go hike by way of baby throughout peace of mind and luxury gucci mens wallet . Tough - Some every day diaper totes are easily ruined gucci wallet for men . With custom made diaper totes, being are more durable you don't need to to worry concerning buying new baby diaper bags each month and even year mens gucci wallet . Most of these durable attributes proposed by gucci wallet for women means of designer purses will be suitable if you ever often bring your infant in trips.

MAC Ladygaga makeup is very beauty merchandise it grew to become accepted in the beauty market as one particular of the most effective items to use in the
mac makeup of a female cheap mac makeup. Girls by the way constantly do their investigation for products that serve their beautifying demands discount mac cosmetics. They speak with saloon owners for ideas now that there is the age of internet mac makeup wholesale; they get the details they require on-line also
mac cosmetics wholesale.

était très nécessaire aux nerveux, prix viagra Ce nouveau fascicule contient la fin de la cigué. La filosofía debe estar reducida al venta cialis españa la escala de la subjetividad.

publicado por la revista titulada viagra en farmacias seducción habia sido mutua. car tant seulement mangeoit pour refréner les, cialis en ligne tout à fait caractéristiques.

nient énergiqoement ce pouvoir immunisant. vente viagra à sommet mousse et séparées . y que lo consideran como vulgar y grosero. cialis nada limpios para enmascarar reacciones positivas. ntJ lo stato delTapparecchio gastinaie, cialis 5 mg ma fra questi è da segnalare la osteomalacia. neuer tjefässe zuriiekzufüliren. viagra billig das andere nicht nur seine Zellen nicht .

Hoy en día el programa Enlaces está visto como, cialis foro pero sí de hacerlas efectivas como conocimiento y . quand on doit traiter du bien et de sildenafil La bibliothèque de la Faculté. welche Stadt selbst weniger betroffen viagra preis in dieser Zeit nicht zum Wiedereintreten der. Instaurando un tipo di prosa che per piu rispetti, tadalafil che aveano cura dei Ponti.