Question of the Week

Podcast Question of the Week – Episode 111

Hermione and Harry find themselves in over their heads in this chapter, first with centaurs and then with Grawp. We want to know how YOU would have written it! The question is as follows:

We’ve presented a few options (on Episode 111) for how to revise this chapter in regard to the actions taken in the forest, citing uncharacteristic moves by main characters and potentially unnecessary events. Some of our suggested changes included Grawp’s involvement, Hermione’s choices, changing the actions of the centaurs, and even Umbridge. Even the Order of the Phoenix film has presented an alternative. If you could present an alternative way to make these events play out, maintaining Rowling’s flair for twists and recalling plot elements, would you utilize any of the suggestions presented? In what other ways could you tie everything together to get Harry and Hermione out of the forest and reunite the “Dream Team”?

Let us know your thoughts in the comments below and tune in next week to see if your ideas are discussed on the show!